Effects of selective outcome reporting on risk perception F
Abstract
Effects of selective outcome reporting on risk perception F Freudenstein, R J Croft, S P Loughran, B M Zeleke, P M Wiedemann. Effects of selective outcome reporting on risk perception. Environ Res. 2021 Feb 3;110821. doi: 10.1016/j.envres.2021.110821. Highlights • An experimental study investigated how selective reporting of study results - indicating increased health effects - influenced its receiver’s risk perception. • Selective reporting of risk information increased risk perception when compared to receiving the full information. • Selectively informed subjects revealed a stronger tendency towards overgeneralization of health risks. • The results indicate that reporting of full study results is an important factor in effective risk communication. Abstract The current study aimed to investigate how selective reporting of study results indicating increased health effects will influence its receiver's risk perception. Using the example of the Interphone Study from 2010 on mobile phone usage and cancer, an online experiment was conducted separating respondents into two groups. One group of subjects was informed selectively about a relationship between heavy mobile phone use and an elevated risk of glioma (brain cancer) only. The other group of subjects was informed about the full results of the analyses of glioma risk by cumulative call time, which suggests that other than for the heavy users, there were no statistically significant elevated risks related to mobile phone use. The results showed that selective reporting of risk information increased risk perception when compared to receiving the full information. Additionally, the selectively informed subjects revealed a stronger tendency towards overgeneralization of the 'elevated brain cancer risk' to all mobile phone users, although this did not extend to an overgeneralization to other electromagnetic field sources or differences in the perception of a usage time dependency for possible health risks. These results indicate that reporting of full results is an important factor in effective risk communication. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov
AI evidence extraction
Main findings
In an online experiment using information framed from the Interphone Study (2010), participants who received selectively reported results indicating increased health effects showed higher risk perception than those who received the full results. Selectively informed participants more often overgeneralized an elevated brain cancer (glioma) risk to all mobile phone users, but this did not extend to overgeneralization to other EMF sources or to differences in perceived usage-time dependency.
Outcomes measured
- Risk perception
- Overgeneralization of perceived brain cancer risk (glioma) to all mobile phone users
- Perception of usage time dependency for possible health risks
- Overgeneralization to other electromagnetic field sources (risk perception)
Limitations
- Sample size not reported in provided abstract/metadata
- Population characteristics not reported in provided abstract/metadata
- Exposure parameters (frequency
- SAR
- actual exposure) not reported
- study concerns communication of study results rather than measuring EMF exposure
- Uses Interphone Study results as an example
- findings pertain to selective reporting effects on perception
Suggested hubs
- who-icnirp (0.7)Addresses risk communication and interpretation of evidence about mobile phone RF and cancer, relevant to major health-risk assessment frameworks.
View raw extracted JSON
{
"study_type": "other",
"exposure": {
"band": "RF",
"source": "mobile phone",
"frequency_mhz": null,
"sar_wkg": null,
"duration": null
},
"population": null,
"sample_size": null,
"outcomes": [
"Risk perception",
"Overgeneralization of perceived brain cancer risk (glioma) to all mobile phone users",
"Perception of usage time dependency for possible health risks",
"Overgeneralization to other electromagnetic field sources (risk perception)"
],
"main_findings": "In an online experiment using information framed from the Interphone Study (2010), participants who received selectively reported results indicating increased health effects showed higher risk perception than those who received the full results. Selectively informed participants more often overgeneralized an elevated brain cancer (glioma) risk to all mobile phone users, but this did not extend to overgeneralization to other EMF sources or to differences in perceived usage-time dependency.",
"effect_direction": "harm",
"limitations": [
"Sample size not reported in provided abstract/metadata",
"Population characteristics not reported in provided abstract/metadata",
"Exposure parameters (frequency, SAR, actual exposure) not reported; study concerns communication of study results rather than measuring EMF exposure",
"Uses Interphone Study results as an example; findings pertain to selective reporting effects on perception"
],
"evidence_strength": "low",
"confidence": 0.74,
"peer_reviewed_likely": "yes",
"keywords": [
"selective outcome reporting",
"risk communication",
"risk perception",
"mobile phone",
"glioma",
"brain cancer",
"Interphone Study",
"electromagnetic fields"
],
"suggested_hubs": [
{
"slug": "who-icnirp",
"weight": 0.25,
"reason": "Addresses risk communication and interpretation of evidence about mobile phone RF and cancer, relevant to major health-risk assessment frameworks."
}
]
}AI can be wrong. Always verify against the paper.
Comments
Log in to comment.
No comments yet.
NNEMF synthesis
Synthesis pending.