(In)accuracy and convergent validity of daily end-of-day and single-time self-reported estimations of smartphone use among
Abstract
(In)accuracy and convergent validity of daily end-of-day and single-time self-reported estimations of smartphone use among adolescents Tkaczyk M, Tancoš M, Smahel D, Elavsky S, Plhák J. (In)accuracy and convergent validity of daily end-of- day and single-time self-reported estimations of smartphone use among adolescents. Computers in Human Behavior. Vol. 158, 2024, doi: 10.1016/j.chb.2024.108281. Abstract Understanding the measurement inaccuracy and bias introduced by self-reports of smartphone use is essential for making meaningful inferences about smartphone use and its effects. Evidence for the self- reports of smartphone use in intensive longitudinal studies is largely missing. Based on self-reported and digital trace data from 137 Czech adolescents (41% girls, Mage = 14.95 years), this study examined the accuracy, directional bias, and convergent validity of daily end-of-day and single-time reports of screen time and phone-checking behavior. Overall, the study found considerable discrepancies between self- reported smartphone use and digital trace and low between-person convergent validity for all self- reports considered for the study. Respondents usually reported shorter screen time and lower frequency of phone-checking behavior as compared to digital trace, both in daily and single-time self- reports. The within-person convergent validity between daily reports and digital tracking was low, indicating poor self-reports ability to capture the actual day-to-day fluctuations in smartphone use. This study adds to the existing evidence showing that self-reports based insights into how people use smartphones differ considerably from digital trace data and shows that both person and situational levels contribute to explaining the discrepancy between digital trace and self-report data among adolescents. : sciencedirect.com
AI evidence extraction
Main findings
In 137 Czech adolescents, self-reported daily end-of-day and single-time estimates of screen time and phone-checking showed considerable discrepancies compared with digital trace data and low between-person convergent validity. Participants generally underreported screen time and phone-checking frequency relative to digital trace, and within-person convergent validity for daily reports was low, indicating poor capture of day-to-day fluctuations.
Outcomes measured
- Accuracy of self-reported smartphone use vs digital trace data
- Directional bias in self-reported screen time
- Directional bias in self-reported phone-checking frequency
- Between-person convergent validity of self-reports vs digital trace
- Within-person convergent validity of daily reports vs digital tracking (day-to-day fluctuations)
View raw extracted JSON
{
"study_type": "other",
"exposure": {
"band": null,
"source": "smartphone",
"frequency_mhz": null,
"sar_wkg": null,
"duration": null
},
"population": "Czech adolescents",
"sample_size": 137,
"outcomes": [
"Accuracy of self-reported smartphone use vs digital trace data",
"Directional bias in self-reported screen time",
"Directional bias in self-reported phone-checking frequency",
"Between-person convergent validity of self-reports vs digital trace",
"Within-person convergent validity of daily reports vs digital tracking (day-to-day fluctuations)"
],
"main_findings": "In 137 Czech adolescents, self-reported daily end-of-day and single-time estimates of screen time and phone-checking showed considerable discrepancies compared with digital trace data and low between-person convergent validity. Participants generally underreported screen time and phone-checking frequency relative to digital trace, and within-person convergent validity for daily reports was low, indicating poor capture of day-to-day fluctuations.",
"effect_direction": "unclear",
"limitations": [],
"evidence_strength": "moderate",
"confidence": 0.74,
"peer_reviewed_likely": "unknown",
"keywords": [
"smartphone use",
"self-report",
"digital trace data",
"screen time",
"phone checking",
"adolescents",
"measurement accuracy",
"convergent validity",
"intensive longitudinal studies"
],
"suggested_hubs": []
}AI can be wrong. Always verify against the paper.
Comments
Log in to comment.
No comments yet.
NNEMF synthesis
Synthesis pending.