Share

Health-Economics Analyses Applied to ELF Electric and Magnetic Fields.

Shaiela Kandel, John Swanson, Leeka Kheifets

PAPERpubmedRisk analysis : an official publication of the Society for Risk Analysis2016ReviewEffect: unclearEvidence: Insufficient

Abstract

Extremely low frequency electric and magnetic fields (ELF EMFs) are a common exposure for modern populations. The prevailing public-health protection paradigm is that quantitative exposure limits are based on the established acute effects, whereas the possible chronic effects are considered too uncertain for quantitative limits, but might justify precautionary measures. The choice of precautionary measures can be informed by a health-economics analysis (HEA). We consider four such analyses of precautionary measures that have been conducted at a national or state level in California, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, and Israel. We describe the context of each analysis, examine how they deal with some of the more significant issues that arise, and present a comparison of the input parameters and assumptions used. The four HEAs are methodologically similar. The most significant qualitative choices that have to be made are what dose-response relationship to assume, what allowance if any to make for uncertainty, and, for a CBA only, what diseases to consider, and all four analyses made similar choices. These analyses suggest that, on the assumptions made, there are some low-cost measures, such as rephasing, that can be applied to transmission in some circumstances and that can be justifiable in cost-benefit terms, but that higher cost measures, such as undergrounding, become unjustifiable. Of the four HEAs, those in the United Kingdom and Israel were influential in determining the country's EMF policy. In California and Netherlands, the HEA may well have informed the debate, but the policy chosen did not stem directly from the HEA.

AI evidence extraction

At a glance
Study type
Review
Effect direction
unclear
Population
Modern populations (general exposure context)
Sample size
—
Exposure
ELF <1 MHz
Evidence strength
Insufficient
Confidence: 74% · Peer-reviewed: yes

Main findings

The paper reviews four national/state-level health-economics analyses (California, Netherlands, United Kingdom, Israel) of precautionary measures for ELF electric and magnetic fields and compares their assumptions and parameters. Under the assumptions used in these analyses, some low-cost measures (e.g., rephasing) may be justifiable in cost-benefit terms in some circumstances, whereas higher-cost measures (e.g., undergrounding) become unjustifiable. The HEAs in the United Kingdom and Israel were influential in national EMF policy; in California and the Netherlands they may have informed debate but did not directly determine policy.

Outcomes measured

  • Health-economics analysis (HEA) of precautionary measures
  • Cost-benefit justification of mitigation measures
  • Policy influence of HEA on EMF policy

Limitations

  • Review is based on four existing HEAs and their assumptions
  • results depend on qualitative choices such as assumed dose-response relationship and treatment of uncertainty.
  • No quantitative exposure metrics (e.g.
  • field strengths
  • frequencies) are provided in the abstract.
  • Health outcomes/diseases considered in the CBAs are not specified in the abstract.

Suggested hubs

  • who-icnirp (0.7)
    Discusses exposure limits paradigm and precautionary measures in public-health protection context for ELF EMFs.
View raw extracted JSON
{
  "study_type": "review",
  "exposure": {
    "band": "ELF",
    "source": null,
    "frequency_mhz": null,
    "sar_wkg": null,
    "duration": null
  },
  "population": "Modern populations (general exposure context)",
  "sample_size": null,
  "outcomes": [
    "Health-economics analysis (HEA) of precautionary measures",
    "Cost-benefit justification of mitigation measures",
    "Policy influence of HEA on EMF policy"
  ],
  "main_findings": "The paper reviews four national/state-level health-economics analyses (California, Netherlands, United Kingdom, Israel) of precautionary measures for ELF electric and magnetic fields and compares their assumptions and parameters. Under the assumptions used in these analyses, some low-cost measures (e.g., rephasing) may be justifiable in cost-benefit terms in some circumstances, whereas higher-cost measures (e.g., undergrounding) become unjustifiable. The HEAs in the United Kingdom and Israel were influential in national EMF policy; in California and the Netherlands they may have informed debate but did not directly determine policy.",
  "effect_direction": "unclear",
  "limitations": [
    "Review is based on four existing HEAs and their assumptions; results depend on qualitative choices such as assumed dose-response relationship and treatment of uncertainty.",
    "No quantitative exposure metrics (e.g., field strengths, frequencies) are provided in the abstract.",
    "Health outcomes/diseases considered in the CBAs are not specified in the abstract."
  ],
  "evidence_strength": "insufficient",
  "confidence": 0.74,
  "peer_reviewed_likely": "yes",
  "keywords": [
    "extremely low frequency",
    "ELF",
    "electric fields",
    "magnetic fields",
    "health economics analysis",
    "cost-benefit analysis",
    "precautionary measures",
    "rephasing",
    "undergrounding",
    "EMF policy",
    "exposure limits"
  ],
  "suggested_hubs": [
    {
      "slug": "who-icnirp",
      "weight": 0.32,
      "reason": "Discusses exposure limits paradigm and precautionary measures in public-health protection context for ELF EMFs."
    }
  ]
}

AI can be wrong. Always verify against the paper.

AI-extracted fields are generated from the abstract/metadata and may be incomplete or incorrect. This content is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice.

Comments

Log in to comment.

No comments yet.

NNEMF synthesis

Synthesis pending.

Original record: rfsafe.org paper 4883

Health-Economics Analyses Applied to ELF Electric and Magnetic Fields. · Non-native EMF