Share

Autonomous nervous system responses to environmental-level exposure to 5G's first deployed band

PAPERmanualExperimental Physiology2024randomized trialEffect: mixedEvidence: Low

Abstract

Autonomous nervous system responses to environmental-level exposure to 5G's first deployed band (3.5 GHz) in healthy human volunteers Jamal L, Michelant L, Delanaud S, Hugueville L, Mazet P, Lévêque P, Baz T, Bach V, Selmaoui B. Autonomous nervous system responses to environmental-level exposure to 5G's first deployed band (3.5 GHz) in healthy human volunteers. Exp Physiol. 2024 Oct 15. doi: 10.1113/EP092083. Abstract Following the global progressive deployment of 5G networks, considerable attention has focused on assessing their potential impact on human health. This study aims to investigate autonomous nervous system changes by exploring skin temperature and electrodermal activity (EDA) among 44 healthy young individuals of both sexes during and after exposure to 3.5 GHz antenna-emitted signals, with an electrical field intensity ranging from 1 to 2 V/m. The study employed a randomized, cross-over design with triple-blinding, encompassing both 'real' and 'sham' exposure sessions, separated by a maximum interval of 1 week. Each session comprised baseline, exposure and postexposure phases, resulting in the acquisition of seven runs. Each run initiated with a 150 s segment of EDA recordings stimulated by 10 repeated beeps. Subsequently, the collected data underwent continuous decomposition analysis, generating specific indicators assessed alongside standard metrics such as trough-to-peak measurements, global skin conductance and maximum positive peak deflection. Additionally, non- invasive, real-time skin temperature measurements were conducted to evaluate specific anatomical points (hand, head and neck). The study suggests that exposure to 3.5 GHz signals may potentially affect head and neck temperature, indicating a slight increase in this parameter. Furthermore, there was a minimal modulation of certain electrodermal metrics after the exposure, suggesting a potentially faster physiological response to auditory stimulation. However, while the results are significant, they remain within the normal physiological range and could be a consequence of an uncontrolled variable. Given the preliminary nature of this pilot study, further research is needed to confirm the effects of 5G exposure. : physoc.onlinelibrary.wiley.com

AI evidence extraction

At a glance
Study type
randomized trial
Effect direction
mixed
Population
44 healthy young individuals of both sexes (healthy human volunteers)
Sample size
44
Exposure
RF 5G antenna-emitted signals · 3500 MHz
Evidence strength
Low
Confidence: 78% · Peer-reviewed: yes

Main findings

In a randomized, cross-over, triple-blind real vs sham exposure study at 3.5 GHz (1–2 V/m), the authors report a slight increase in head and neck temperature during/after exposure and minimal modulation of some electrodermal metrics after exposure, suggesting a potentially faster response to auditory stimulation. The reported changes were statistically significant but remained within normal physiological ranges and may reflect an uncontrolled variable; the study is described as preliminary/pilot.

Outcomes measured

  • Skin temperature (hand
  • head
  • neck)
  • Electrodermal activity (EDA) metrics (e.g.
  • trough-to-peak
  • global skin conductance
  • maximum positive peak deflection
  • decomposition-derived indicators)
  • Physiological response to auditory stimulation (beep-stimulated EDA)

Limitations

  • Pilot/preliminary study
  • authors call for confirmation
  • Observed effects remained within normal physiological range
  • Authors note effects could be due to an uncontrolled variable
  • Exposure duration not specified in abstract

Suggested hubs

  • 5g-policy (0.7)
    Study evaluates physiological responses to 5G (3.5 GHz) environmental-level exposure in humans.
View raw extracted JSON
{
  "study_type": "randomized_trial",
  "exposure": {
    "band": "RF",
    "source": "5G antenna-emitted signals",
    "frequency_mhz": 3500,
    "sar_wkg": null,
    "duration": null
  },
  "population": "44 healthy young individuals of both sexes (healthy human volunteers)",
  "sample_size": 44,
  "outcomes": [
    "Skin temperature (hand, head, neck)",
    "Electrodermal activity (EDA) metrics (e.g., trough-to-peak, global skin conductance, maximum positive peak deflection; decomposition-derived indicators)",
    "Physiological response to auditory stimulation (beep-stimulated EDA)"
  ],
  "main_findings": "In a randomized, cross-over, triple-blind real vs sham exposure study at 3.5 GHz (1–2 V/m), the authors report a slight increase in head and neck temperature during/after exposure and minimal modulation of some electrodermal metrics after exposure, suggesting a potentially faster response to auditory stimulation. The reported changes were statistically significant but remained within normal physiological ranges and may reflect an uncontrolled variable; the study is described as preliminary/pilot.",
  "effect_direction": "mixed",
  "limitations": [
    "Pilot/preliminary study; authors call for confirmation",
    "Observed effects remained within normal physiological range",
    "Authors note effects could be due to an uncontrolled variable",
    "Exposure duration not specified in abstract"
  ],
  "evidence_strength": "low",
  "confidence": 0.78,
  "peer_reviewed_likely": "yes",
  "keywords": [
    "5G",
    "3.5 GHz",
    "RF exposure",
    "environmental-level exposure",
    "electric field intensity",
    "1–2 V/m",
    "randomized cross-over",
    "triple-blind",
    "sham exposure",
    "skin temperature",
    "electrodermal activity",
    "autonomic nervous system"
  ],
  "suggested_hubs": [
    {
      "slug": "5g-policy",
      "weight": 0.62,
      "reason": "Study evaluates physiological responses to 5G (3.5 GHz) environmental-level exposure in humans."
    }
  ]
}

AI can be wrong. Always verify against the paper.

AI-extracted fields are generated from the abstract/metadata and may be incomplete or incorrect. This content is for informational purposes only and is not medical advice.

Comments

Log in to comment.

No comments yet.

NNEMF synthesis

Jamal and colleagues measured autonomic nervous system output in 44 healthy young adults of both sexes during and after a single environmental-level exposure to 3.5 GHz, the first widely deployed 5G band. The design was randomized, crossover, and triple-blind, with real and sham sessions separated by at most one week. Each session had baseline, exposure, and post-exposure phases, giving seven runs. Electric field intensity was 1 to 2 V/m. Specific absorption rate (SAR, the energy the body absorbs) is not reported, so a numerical comparison with the 1.6 watts per kilogram phone limit cannot be made. At 1 to 2 V/m this is an environmental field, far below the intensity of a handset against the head, and the authors treat it as non-heating. Skin temperature was recorded in real time at the hand, head, and neck. Electrodermal activity (EDA, the electrical conductance of the skin, which tracks sympathetic sweat-gland drive) was recorded for 150 seconds in each run while 10 repeated beeps were played. Continuous decomposition analysis produced indicators that were scored with trough-to-peak amplitude, global skin conductance, and maximum positive peak deflection. The authors report a slight increase in head and neck temperature, not hand temperature, and a minimal modulation of certain electrodermal metrics after exposure, which they read as a potentially faster physiological response to the auditory beeps. Both changes were statistically notable but stayed inside the normal physiological range. The authors themselves say the shifts could be an uncontrolled variable, call the work a pilot, and ask for confirmation. That is a mixed, small, non-thermal signal in healthy young adults, not a disease finding and not a null. A change in skin temperature and in the timing of a sweat-gland response at a field that does not heat tissue is a biological response, not a heating artifact. The framework does not treat this as radiofrequency causing a named disease. It treats it as a loss of precision in regulatory timing: the sympathetic output that sets local blood flow and sweat-gland conductance arrived slightly differently under the field than under sham. The receiving tissue here is skin and the autonomic nerves that drive it, which are voltage-sensitive and calcium-timed. The study did not measure channel gating, calcium timing, mitochondrial redox, or spin chemistry, so those arms are not demonstrated. It also did not test recovery after repeated exposure, sex or genotype differences, or a challenge that would show whether reserve was spent. The authors' own caution that an uncontrolled variable could explain the shift is part of the record and is not dismissed. Dose sits next to the limit as a gap, not as a number invented from the field strength. SAR is not reported. The stated intensity, 1 to 2 V/m, is an environmental downlink level, not a phone-against-the-head exposure, and the temperature change the authors describe is a slight regional rise they do not attribute to heating. A regional temperature shift at a non-heating field is the kind of autonomic vasomotor change the framework expects when regulatory timing is slightly off, and it is not evidence that the exposure heated the tissue. The same group later measured the same electrodermal endpoints at 26 GHz and found no change, and separate 26 GHz sessions found no change in salivary cortisol or alpha-amylase and no change in electroencephalogram (EEG) power. Those nulls are not a ceiling on this 3.5 GHz result. Frequency, penetration, and the endpoint differ. A null is possible support and is not a limit on the hypothesis. A null at a different band, in a different tissue coupling, is data about that condition. It does not erase a small timing shift measured at 3.5 GHz in skin temperature and beep-evoked electrodermal response.

Original record: rfsafe.org paper 28

Autonomous nervous system responses to environmental-level exposure to 5G's first deployed band · Non-native EMF